Literacy affected ability to adequately discriminate among categories in multipoint Likert Scales
Accepted 2 March 2008. published online 11 July 2008.
Abstract
Objectives
To assess the effect of inability to read on a five-point Likert scale, using the WHOQOL-BREF response scale. It is hypothesized that inability to read is related to loss of discriminant power among the five-category response scale.
Study Design and Setting
In a cross-sectional design, nonreaders (n=141) and subjects educated at a graduate level (n−907) were assessed. Statistical analyses combined classic and modern psychometric approaches (Confirmatory factor analysis and Rasch analysis).
Results
There is a remarkable difference in the psychometric performance of items across the two subgroups. Fit indexes proved to be closer to the ideal for the graduate group, but not for the nonreader group. Reducing the number of response categories improved the model exclusively for the nonreader sample. Nonreaders do not interpret the scale as a true five-category scale, but exhibit a response pattern indicative that only three categories are in fact considered.
Conclusion
These results confirm the hypothesis that a multiple-category response scale is not suitable for nonreaders. They suggest that a simpler response scale should be adopted to achieve a more reliable and satisfactory psychometric performance in this population. This effect seems to be stronger when more abstract and subjective constructs are involved.
aPost-Graduate Program on Psychiatry, University Federal of Rio Grande do Sul, Rua Florencio Ygartua, 391/308, Porto Alegre – RS, CEP 90430-010, Brazil
bClinical and Health Psychology, Medical School, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
Corresponding author. Post-Graduate Program on Psychiatry, University Federal of Rio Grande do Sul, Rua Florencio Ygartua, 391/308, Porto Alegre – RS, CEP 90430-010. Brazil. Tel.: +55-51-91230015; fax: +55-51-32644152.
ABSTRACT